This is an AI-generated transcript of a video from my old website. Soon I will tidy it up! In the meantime, forgive the terrible writing and punctuation. -Clara
I was in class the other day and I got a fantastic question from a student that I wanted to share with you. The question is this, what are we supposed to do as Christian leaders when our model of leadership is a perfect God-man who always takes everything to God the Father in prayer, who never, you know, loses his temper with his disciples no matter how frustrating they get, who can cast out demons when there are dysfunctional people around the community. And this student just said, like, what am I supposed to do with that? I can’t turn water into wine.
I can’t heal people. I can’t cast out demons. What am I supposed to do? And it really, for me, struck a chord that I’ve been thinking about for the past several years working with, what if the gospels are trying to tell us, not as Christian leaders, not to be like Jesus, but in fact, what if we’re supposed to be like Peter? What if the image of leadership for us in the New Testament is actually Peter? Now, stick with me here for a second because what if Jesus accepts us for all the same things that he accepted Peter for? So we have crises of We misunderstand what it means that Jesus is the Messiah.
We try to manage God rather than following God. We are in the business of managing crowds and trying to keep everything all nice and tidy instead of letting God be God and following where God leads. What if we too can be accepted and loved for those times when we don’t have enough faith, all those times that we have doubts, all those times that we betray or deny Jesus? What if we’re supposed to be like Peter? What if Jesus accepts us as flawed leaders, full of gifts but flawed? And what if Jesus calls us to be brave enough to go on a journey like Peter? Imagine how much courage Peter had to have to accept Jesus’s love once he had betrayed him, once he had denied him.
Just imagine for a second how hard that would have been. And then to have the courage to show up and to try to be some sort of leader amongst the disciples again. And then, you know, I reckon Peter denied Jesus because he was so terrified on the night that Jesus died.
And there he is three months later walking into the temple to proclaim Jesus as the Messiah. What an amazing transformation Peter went through as a The Gospels were written in and for and by communities who already knew Peter as the great pillar of the church, one of the earliest pillars of the church. They wrote about him as a flawed character, I think because they already knew him as a brilliant leader.
So what if we’re not supposed to be like Jesus? Let’s let Jesus do Jesus things. What if we’re supposed to be disciples as leaders, disciples like Peter?